Valerie Cincinelli

Valerie Cincineli is the main villainess behind the planned murder for hire of her husband and her lover's daughter in 2019.

Valerie was a NYPD cop and the wife of Isaiah Carvalho, as well as the mother of Isaiah's two children, though it was also revealed that during her marriage's estrangement, she was involved in a relationship with a wealthy older man. Valerie turned heel in February 2019, when she planned to hire a hit man to kill not only Isaiah, but also the daughter of her wealthy lover, with her motive being money. As revealed in the case, Valerie was upset that she was sharing her police pension with her husband, and she also was unhappy with her rich lover spending his money on his daughter.

The enlisted hitman was another boyfriend of Valerie's, who went straight to the FBI and worked to help arrest the villainess. As revealed in the investigation, Valerie did an internet search on Amy Fisher during her plot, and it was on May 17 that Valerie was arrested for her two murder for hire schemes, and she was quickly fired from the NYPD. The villainous Valerie maintained her innocence, and she faces 10 years for each plot, totaling a potential 20 years in prison if convicted.